I have come to a conclusion: after a 6 month internship in a French PR firm that specialises in fine foods and magazines, 2 weeks in a chic London firm that represents top-end hotels and some post-GCSE work experience with my cousin in beauty PR- I have finally decided that Public Relations is not quite right for me.
The world of PR is heavily stereotyped;
lots of champagne, a variety of freebies, plenty of glamourous events in high
heels and constantly having the opportunity to showcase your creativity.
Although some of this may be glitzy, and PRs certainly all have a story to
tell of that time they organised an event with a zed-list celebrity in a swanky
venue in Paris, the other 99% of their time is spent being frustrated at
ignored emails, annoyed at incorrect journalism and having to be overly
friendly to an unresponsive client.
The working world demands routine, repetition
and admin, but I can’t help thinking that sending hundreds of blankets emails with
text book press releases to interns at crumbling magazines is a little
demoralising, especially when the majority of those emails end up unread. The
rise of influential bloggers has certainly changed this dynamic, there are now
a lot more junk mail folders to send your press releases to, but unless your
incessant emailing is paired with a creative marketing scheme or an original,
and always expensive, advertising campaign, I found it difficult to feel like any impact had been made.
The feeling of seeing one of your clients
featured in the press is certainly a thrill. However, even when you are
successful in your promotion pursuit, the problem with PR is that it is
virtually impossible to measure. The experts suggest that PR value is 3 times the value of
advertising (if a half page advert in the magazine costs £1000, a half page editorial piece would therefore be ‘worth’
£3000). Yet, what I find frustrating is that to know if the writing on those pages transfers into the all-important words on the lips of consumers, well that is almost impossible.
The intangibility of PR certainly contributes in a large way to my decision, but the fundamental turning point is that PR has deteriorated my appreciation of magazines and made me rather cynical about journalism. Journalists can copy and paste a press release straight into their article within minutes without even a full comprehension of the product. This leads to the products represented by the pushiest PRs who happen to be that old-friend-from-school or the most generous PRs (who can offer free trips to the Bahamas) having the largest word count in the press. Even the most inconsistent cynic would point out that this means that there is very little substance behind the statements.
Even though I am highly dubious about the Public Relations-Journalist partnership, I can admit that PR has taught me a lot about business, networking and events. Although I have decided that it's not the career path for me, certainly at this stage, I won't deny that my experiences have been more than worthwhile.
The intangibility of PR certainly contributes in a large way to my decision, but the fundamental turning point is that PR has deteriorated my appreciation of magazines and made me rather cynical about journalism. Journalists can copy and paste a press release straight into their article within minutes without even a full comprehension of the product. This leads to the products represented by the pushiest PRs who happen to be that old-friend-from-school or the most generous PRs (who can offer free trips to the Bahamas) having the largest word count in the press. Even the most inconsistent cynic would point out that this means that there is very little substance behind the statements.
Even though I am highly dubious about the Public Relations-Journalist partnership, I can admit that PR has taught me a lot about business, networking and events. Although I have decided that it's not the career path for me, certainly at this stage, I won't deny that my experiences have been more than worthwhile.
No comments:
Post a Comment